Skip to content

Governance and foundations

Phase 1 of 16 in the complete engineering review.

Applicability, evidence, quality attributes, ownership, risk, ethics, suppliers, people, and continual improvement.

Assess every control as Pass, Fail, Blocked, or Not Applicable. A Pass needs current evidence for the exact product, revision, artifact, configuration, environment, and data state under review.

Applicability, Evidence, Exceptions, and Audit Rules

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/01-applicability-evidence-and-exceptions.md; 61 non-duplicative controls.

Applicability and evidence

  • USEQ-B14FDA8E — Every control is assessed as Pass, Fail, Blocked, or Not Applicable.
  • USEQ-97B150FF — Every Not Applicable result has a written, reviewed rationale tied to system context.
  • USEQ-64B6A3A8 — Every applicable control has one accountable owner and current, reproducible evidence.
  • USEQ-72088469 — Evidence identifies the exact product, source revision, artifact, configuration, environment, data state, and date assessed.
  • USEQ-CD2F9D5E — Material changes invalidate affected evidence and trigger proportionate reassessment.
  • USEQ-6E42CC84 — Exceptions are time-bounded, risk-owned, monitored, documented, and automatically expire.
  • USEQ-2798897B — A control operated by a supplier or platform remains in scope; responsibility may be shared but accountability is not outsourced.
  • USEQ-B9A1C5BC — A serious unresolved failure in this category can block release regardless of aggregate checklist completion.

Universal applicability rules

  • USEQ-E8F15536 — Establish the product, service, system, organization, release, and lifecycle boundaries being assessed.
  • USEQ-5657EBD9 — List every component, repository, artifact, environment, data store, interface, user class, role, supplier, location, and operational process in scope.
  • USEQ-C8C131DB — Identify which conditional-domain modules are triggered by capabilities, users, data, jurisdiction, contract, or risk.
  • USEQ-75497572 — Assess every checklist item; omission is not a valid status.
  • USEQ-3A8A5F50 — Use only Pass, Fail, Blocked, or Not Applicable as assessment statuses.
  • USEQ-683B6299 — Treat Blocked as a failure for final approval unless an authorized decision explicitly states otherwise.
  • USEQ-8137C823 — Require a specific rationale for every Not Applicable decision.
  • USEQ-D7F6AF3B — Reject Not Applicable rationales based only on inconvenience, cost, ownership elsewhere, tool limitations, or lack of implementation.
  • USEQ-F0272B02 — Assign one accountable owner to every applicable control and every exception.
  • USEQ-7375F93B — Identify the qualified reviewer and preserve reviewer independence for material controls.
  • USEQ-5FB50410 — Tie evidence to the exact source revision, artifact digest, configuration, schema, flags, environment, dependency versions, and data state.
  • USEQ-4004F77F — Reject evidence from a different release or environment unless equivalence is demonstrated.
  • USEQ-59870003 — Define evidence validity periods according to change rate, threat change, supplier change, and control volatility.
  • USEQ-569D2912 — Invalidate evidence after any material change that can affect the conclusion.
  • USEQ-DB6244DF — Use sampling only with a documented population, method, coverage, confidence, limitations, and risk rationale.
  • USEQ-22F43D4B — Prefer direct evidence of operation over policy statements, plans, intentions, or screenshots without context.
  • USEQ-56521362 — Require evidence that compensating controls work under the conditions in which the primary control is absent.
  • USEQ-41204E99 — Record residual risk after controls, not only inherent risk before controls.
  • USEQ-97E5A6C1 — Prohibit averaging or scoring that allows a critical failure to be offset by unrelated passes.
  • USEQ-08DC1879 — Define release-blocking and nonblocking severity before assessment results are known.
  • USEQ-01B6090D — Escalate conflicts between quality attributes to an authorized multidisciplinary decision owner.
  • USEQ-08130ED1 — Preserve evidence in a durable, access-controlled, searchable, and immutable or tamper-evident form proportionate to risk.
  • USEQ-3AC76487 — Protect assessment evidence from exposing secrets, personal data, vulnerabilities, or customer information.
  • USEQ-0DAF2834 — Review provider and inherited controls while preserving customer-side responsibilities.
  • USEQ-38E46EF2 — Repeat assessment after incidents, escaped defects, major findings, jurisdiction changes, supplier changes, and significant scale change.
  • USEQ-35B75024 — Maintain historical assessments with historical releases and do not overwrite past conclusions.
  • USEQ-24057956 — Use the corpus as a baseline and add domain, organization, product, and jurisdiction controls without silently deleting universal controls.

Minimum evidence record

  • USEQ-D135E510 — Control identifier and complete control text.
  • USEQ-ECC769B0 — Assessment status.
  • USEQ-4A3D6129 — Applicability rationale.
  • USEQ-6D3C345E — Accountable owner.
  • USEQ-8D90ACE7 — Implementing owner or team.
  • USEQ-1015BBD0 — Qualified reviewer and approval.
  • USEQ-9FE92874 — Evidence location and access classification.
  • USEQ-5E2E1223 — Evidence date and expiry.
  • USEQ-F1DF60DF — System, component, environment, source revision, artifact digest, configuration, schema, flags, and dependency context.
  • USEQ-F5B88725 — Test method, data, tools, versions, assumptions, and limitations.
  • USEQ-C8D18281 — Observed result and threshold.
  • USEQ-2989132F — Linked defect, risk, exception, incident, or corrective action.
  • USEQ-89722999 — Reassessment trigger.

Exception and risk-acceptance rules

  • USEQ-9EEBC544 — Identify the exact unmet control and why remediation is not complete.
  • USEQ-62B384A0 — Describe affected users, systems, data, operations, and business outcomes.
  • USEQ-4F2BE7CE — Assess likelihood, impact, exploitability, reach, detectability, recoverability, and duration.
  • USEQ-D947B87C — Document existing and proposed compensating controls.
  • USEQ-EB9477C4 — Demonstrate compensating controls with current evidence.
  • USEQ-0D775A08 — Define monitoring and alert thresholds specific to the accepted risk.
  • USEQ-C208D665 — Assign an authorized risk owner with authority over the consequences.
  • USEQ-27A4BEB6 — Set a remediation owner, funded plan, target date, and automatic expiry.
  • USEQ-4E4FE3D7 — Define conditions that immediately revoke the exception.
  • USEQ-238A650D — Prevent exceptions from silently renewing or becoming permanent architecture.
  • USEQ-EB30F057 — Review cumulative risk from multiple individually accepted exceptions.
  • USEQ-841F7705 — Communicate the exception to operators, support, security, privacy, product, and customers where appropriate.
  • USEQ-DAE761C7 — Close the exception only after remediation and independent verification.

Universal Software and Product Quality Attribute Model

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/02-universal-quality-attribute-model.md; 62 non-duplicative controls.

Quality planning rules

  • USEQ-DBA8DAE2 — Select and rank quality attributes according to users, context, criticality, law, contract, threat, failure cost, and product strategy.
  • USEQ-706F2C82 — Define measurable scenarios and acceptance thresholds for every material quality attribute.
  • USEQ-8CB19F4F — State trade-offs explicitly and prevent one quality attribute from being optimized by silently harming another.
  • USEQ-8D9F2BD3 — Use both product-quality evidence and real-world quality-in-use evidence.
  • USEQ-03A9E0A8 — Measure distributions, edge populations, and degraded conditions rather than averages alone.
  • USEQ-6DD9714D — Define quality budgets and regression limits before implementation and launch.
  • USEQ-F30FF972 — Assign ownership for each quality objective and each cross-attribute conflict.
  • USEQ-A5FC207A — Maintain traceability from quality objectives to architecture tactics, code, tests, monitoring, and operational decisions.
  • USEQ-4D15E15B — Review quality objectives after material change, incident, scale increase, new user population, or new regulation.
  • USEQ-0EDC049D — Do not declare overall quality from a single metric, tool score, certification, test level, or absence of reported defects.

Product-quality characteristics

Functional suitability

  • USEQ-086B1E7E — All required functions are present for the intended tasks and contexts.
  • USEQ-96E895D9 — Results, calculations, state transitions, permissions, and side effects are correct.
  • USEQ-4386DEDD — Functions enable users to complete intended tasks without unnecessary or inappropriate behavior.
  • USEQ-AF45F27F — Exceptional, degraded, recovery, cancellation, and prohibited behavior is defined and verified.

Performance efficiency

  • USEQ-83E0B216 — Latency, throughput, responsiveness, and completion time meet defined objectives under specified conditions.
  • USEQ-F3FC8AD5 — Compute, memory, storage, network, energy, and external-service use are proportionate to outcomes.
  • USEQ-31D05A91 — Capacity limits and safe overload behavior are known and tested.
  • USEQ-769066B0 — Performance remains acceptable across representative devices, networks, data volumes, tenants, and failure conditions.

Compatibility

  • USEQ-5104BA7F — The product coexists safely with other software, workloads, users, and tenants in shared environments.
  • USEQ-09B7C249 — Information exchange preserves syntax, semantics, precision, identity, ordering, privacy, and authorization.
  • USEQ-2DF76BC4 — Supported versions, formats, clients, protocols, and environments interoperate as promised.
  • USEQ-BB1B1C78 — Incompatible changes use controlled negotiation, migration, deprecation, and retirement.

Interaction capability

  • USEQ-311C0D5C — Users can recognize whether the product is appropriate to their goal.
  • USEQ-2AAD63D5 — Users can learn and operate the product effectively with reasonable effort.
  • USEQ-DB083136 — The product prevents, identifies, explains, and supports recovery from user error.
  • USEQ-E539A311 — The experience is inclusive across relevant abilities, language, literacy, device, input, and context.
  • USEQ-1865C898 — Help, feedback, status, and self-description make the system understandable.
  • USEQ-4BD5F349 — Engagement patterns preserve autonomy and do not manipulate users.

Reliability

  • USEQ-C3A94BE9 — The product performs required functions without unacceptable faults under specified conditions.
  • USEQ-427C1469 — The service is available according to user-centric objectives.
  • USEQ-02155A34 — Faults are contained and do not cascade unnecessarily.
  • USEQ-1156B06C — State and service can recover within approved time, point, integrity, and continuity objectives.
  • USEQ-6DAFFC83 — Reliability remains valid during deployment, dependency failure, overload, maintenance, and disaster scenarios.

Security

  • USEQ-69A431A2 — Information and operations are confidential to unauthorized parties.
  • USEQ-ED5F3FB0 — Data, code, configuration, identities, and actions retain integrity.
  • USEQ-971B3218 — Material actions are attributable and appropriately auditable.
  • USEQ-88D972E4 — Identities, services, devices, artifacts, and messages are authenticated at required assurance.
  • USEQ-E3BBAE93 — The product resists attack, abuse, control bypass, compromise, and unauthorized recovery.
  • USEQ-CC0B63FE — Security remains effective across development, supply chain, deployment, operation, and retirement.

Maintainability

  • USEQ-72137EBC — The system is modular enough to localize understanding, change, testing, and failure.
  • USEQ-72AA3B4E — Useful assets can be reused without unsafe coupling or semantic mismatch.
  • USEQ-636F1705 — Defects, behavior, dependencies, state, and performance can be analyzed efficiently.
  • USEQ-D5503076 — Changes can be implemented, reviewed, verified, deployed, and reversed safely.
  • USEQ-2A27E944 — Ownership, documentation, tests, tooling, and environments support future maintainers.

Flexibility

  • USEQ-0BDD9349 — The product can adapt to required environments, users, workloads, and configuration without uncontrolled redesign.
  • USEQ-B0202719 — The product scales to required demand while preserving quality and safe overload behavior.
  • USEQ-2329A8C0 — Installation, deployment, configuration, upgrade, and migration are reliable and supportable.
  • USEQ-3F04BFB9 — Critical components and providers can be replaced where continuity or strategy requires it.
  • USEQ-98F2CE0F — The product is testable through controllable inputs, observable outputs, isolation, and reproducibility.

Safety

  • USEQ-C5CB4E01 — Operational constraints prevent the system from entering unacceptable hazardous states.
  • USEQ-543A1786 — Foreseeable hazards and affected people, property, business, software, and environment are identified.
  • USEQ-0737D264 — The product fails safe or limits harm when required assumptions or dependencies fail.
  • USEQ-1042DCD3 — Users and operators receive timely, perceptible, actionable warnings.
  • USEQ-8F9C2013 — Integration with other systems does not invalidate safety controls.
  • USEQ-709154B4 — Residual safety risk is independently reviewed and accepted only by authorized leadership.

Quality in use

  • USEQ-B878B774 — Representative users achieve intended goals accurately and completely.
  • USEQ-0E7B4A58 — Users achieve goals with acceptable time, effort, cognitive load, cost, and resource use.
  • USEQ-6997B2CE — Users experience acceptable trust, comfort, usefulness, and satisfaction without manipulation.
  • USEQ-15BC2C00 — Use avoids unacceptable economic, health, safety, privacy, security, social, and environmental risk.
  • USEQ-09CD9184 — Quality remains acceptable across the full range of intended and foreseeable contexts.
  • USEQ-3980950F — The product supports users when context changes through interruption, disability, stress, low connectivity, device limitation, or emergency.
  • USEQ-3FCB5EB3 — Real-world outcomes are monitored and used to revise product-quality assumptions.

Standards and Frameworks Crosswalk

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/03-standards-and-frameworks-crosswalk.md; 8 non-duplicative controls.

How to use this crosswalk

  • USEQ-E2576411 — Treat this as a broad baseline catalog, not a claim that every listed reference applies to every product.
  • USEQ-429A53EC — Create an applicability register based on system type, users, data, jurisdictions, sector, contracts, safety impact, suppliers, and deployment model.
  • USEQ-42342CFA — Verify the current published edition directly with the issuing body before audit, procurement, certification, or compliance claims.
  • USEQ-16C2ACD8 — Distinguish published standards from drafts, committee drafts, proposed revisions, guidance, and awareness lists.
  • USEQ-AC5D537E — Obtain and use the authoritative text when conformance is required; this corpus does not reproduce copyrighted requirements.
  • USEQ-1F1280E6 — Add sector-specific standards for medical, automotive, aviation, rail, industrial, financial, government, telecommunications, energy, education, and other regulated domains.
  • USEQ-46BFC86D — Record which clauses or outcomes map to local controls, owners, evidence, and exceptions.
  • USEQ-9E85DA5A — Review the register at least annually and after new jurisdictions, products, data, incidents, contracts, or standards revisions.

Universal Definition of Done

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/04-universal-definition-of-done.md; 35 non-duplicative controls.

A work item is not done until every applicable condition passes

Product and requirements

  • USEQ-5BE34669 — The user, business, regulatory, risk, or platform outcome is explicit.
  • USEQ-CD293CE7 — Scope, non-scope, assumptions, constraints, dependencies, and acceptance criteria are approved.
  • USEQ-C7ED66D6 — Functional and quality requirements are testable and traceable.
  • USEQ-FAB421AD — Relevant user research and stakeholder validation are complete.
  • USEQ-4F358A61 — Privacy, security, accessibility, reliability, data, support, and lifecycle requirements are included.

Design and architecture

  • USEQ-8016290C — The design satisfies requirements with justified trade-offs and no unnecessary complexity.
  • USEQ-F40624A5 — System, data, identity, trust, state, failure, operational, and migration implications are understood.
  • USEQ-FE5FCB37 — Material decisions and alternatives are recorded.
  • USEQ-41DCA413 — Threat, abuse, privacy, accessibility, and failure analysis is complete.
  • USEQ-4E5214F8 — Compatibility, rollout, rollback or roll-forward, and retirement are designed.

Implementation

  • USEQ-46552445 — Code is correct, readable, cohesive, appropriately simple, and follows approved standards.
  • USEQ-9FE5701E — SOLID, DRY, KISS, YAGNI, reuse, and abstraction principles are applied contextually rather than mechanically.
  • USEQ-F83FD40A — Input, output, identity, authorization, errors, concurrency, resources, configuration, and secrets are handled safely.
  • USEQ-2282B35E — Dependencies are necessary, approved, supported, licensed, pinned, inventoried, and monitored.
  • USEQ-00E007D5 — Dead code, debug paths, temporary privileges, stale flags, and obsolete compatibility are removed or explicitly lifecycle-managed.

Verification

  • USEQ-4F6B6D16 — Unit, component, integration, contract, system, acceptance, regression, and exploratory testing are complete as applicable.
  • USEQ-7173A5C6 — Positive, negative, boundary, race, retry, failure, recovery, migration, and misuse cases are covered.
  • USEQ-C2EE6972 — Security, privacy, accessibility, performance, reliability, compatibility, and data quality objectives have evidence.
  • USEQ-F266538C — Tests can fail for the defects they claim to detect and are not silently flaky or skipped.
  • USEQ-21B6514F — The exact releasable artifact and production-representative configuration are verified.

Delivery and operations

  • USEQ-AB3A2C88 — Build provenance, artifact digest, SBOM, signature or attestation, and approvals are available as required.
  • USEQ-5FF05D93 — Configuration, migrations, feature flags, infrastructure, dependencies, and deployment order are versioned and reviewed.
  • USEQ-A8AA064C — Monitoring, logs, metrics, traces, alerts, dashboards, SLOs, runbooks, capacity, and support are ready.
  • USEQ-1D2662B7 — Rollback, roll-forward, restoration, reconciliation, and incident response are tested.
  • USEQ-78BFB1B9 — Ownership, on-call, escalation, supplier support, and customer communication are ready.

Documentation and lifecycle

  • USEQ-75AAF559 — User, support, developer, API, data, architecture, test, security, privacy, and operational documentation is current as applicable.
  • USEQ-F62D0973 — Known limitations, residual risks, exceptions, and deferred work are explicit.
  • USEQ-12852D61 — Release notes, migration, deprecation, and support information are prepared.
  • USEQ-395CFEA4 — Temporary controls have owners and expiry dates.
  • USEQ-1ADFF5EF — Evidence and decisions are retained and linked to the exact change.

Final acceptance

  • USEQ-3B007012 — All release blockers are resolved.
  • USEQ-8864F7C9 — No known residual risk exceeds authorized tolerance.
  • USEQ-AE200A41 — Required independent reviews and sign-offs are complete.
  • USEQ-6F9C0838 — The change can be detected, contained, disabled, recovered, and communicated if it fails.
  • USEQ-FB98DCA5 — Post-deployment validation and observation criteria are defined.

Master No-Go Gates

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/05-master-no-go-gates.md; 25 non-duplicative controls.

Absolute release and approval blockers

  • USEQ-6E292740 — A critical user, operator, administrator, recovery, cancellation, or deletion journey lacks successful end-to-end evidence.
  • USEQ-B366F417 — A material requirement or quality objective is undefined, unverified, or contradicted by observed behavior.
  • USEQ-770D5CDF — Authentication, authorization, privileged access, account recovery, or tenant isolation lacks independent verification.
  • USEQ-AD254104 — Known critical or actively exploited exposure remains without demonstrated mitigation and authorized exception.
  • USEQ-C24545ED — A secret, signing key, credential, token, personal record, or sensitive artifact was exposed and not revoked, rotated, contained, and investigated.
  • USEQ-0EB787DF — A destructive, irreversible, or high-volume data change was not rehearsed and cannot be verified or recovered safely.
  • USEQ-B85F89C0 — Backup restoration, disaster recovery, rollback, or safe roll-forward cannot meet approved objectives.
  • USEQ-39949FBC — Expected peak, burst, largest-tenant, abuse, or dependency-failure behavior is unknown.
  • USEQ-8124B601 — Critical user journeys cannot meet approved availability, latency, correctness, durability, freshness, accessibility, security, privacy, or safety objectives.
  • USEQ-26BF004F — Monitoring cannot detect critical journey failure, material data corruption, control bypass, or loss of telemetry.
  • USEQ-AE082DBE — No qualified and authorized responder is available for launch and early operation.
  • USEQ-5958B1BD — Incident, escalation, customer communication, supplier escalation, or breach procedures required by risk do not exist.
  • USEQ-1F972B41 — A mandatory legal, regulatory, contractual, accessibility, privacy, payment, safety, or procurement obligation is unmet.
  • USEQ-9D2FAC3F — The production artifact cannot be traced to reviewed source, declared dependencies, trusted build, tests, provenance, and approval.
  • USEQ-9B701F53 — An unsupported or end-of-life critical component lacks a tested compensating control and funded replacement plan.
  • USEQ-502289C2 — Known cross-user or cross-tenant disclosure, data corruption, duplicate charging, irreversible financial effect, or unsafe act remains possible without a tested control.
  • USEQ-C4B996D3 — A single person, credential, device, region, provider, undocumented procedure, or unavailable control plane is the only recovery path contrary to approved objectives.
  • USEQ-7AA7DE0D — Evidence predates material untested change or refers to another artifact or configuration.
  • USEQ-08296C2C — A blocker was relabeled, suppressed, waived, or marked Not Applicable without authorized evidence-based risk acceptance.
  • USEQ-5BCE4800 — The team cannot state concrete hold, stop, rollback, roll-forward, incident, and communication thresholds before deployment.
  • USEQ-6D298FCF — A serious anomaly, test failure, data mismatch, or security signal remains unexplained.
  • USEQ-2094042A — The only rationale for proceeding is deadline, revenue, sunk cost, executive pressure, or confidence without evidence.
  • USEQ-A2B2E114 — The product uses manipulative, discriminatory, inaccessible, unsafe, or unlawful behavior that has not been removed or explicitly and lawfully constrained.
  • USEQ-E72E7A13 — The system cannot preserve essential records, data integrity, or user rights through failure, migration, recovery, and retirement.
  • USEQ-4401E253 — The organization cannot identify the accountable owner of the product, service, data, security, privacy, operations, and residual risk.

Final Evidence Package

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/06-final-evidence-package.md; 21 non-duplicative controls.

Universal controls

  • USEQ-D4A97289 — Release identifier, source commits, tags, artifact digests, configuration versions, migration versions, and feature-flag states.
  • USEQ-0015A567 — Final scope, asset inventory, architecture diagrams, deployment diagrams, and data-flow diagrams.
  • USEQ-E15E9EEE — Data inventory, classification, retention schedule, and privacy records.
  • USEQ-73265165 — Threat model, abuse-case assessment, risk register, and accepted exceptions.
  • USEQ-0820243E — Applicable legal, privacy, accessibility, security, regulatory, and contractual requirements.
  • USEQ-1777943C — Requirements-to-test and control-to-evidence traceability.
  • USEQ-153FAFE7 — Functional, integration, contract, system, regression, and user-acceptance test results.
  • USEQ-BB6A3F92 — Browser, device, localization, usability, and accessibility results.
  • USEQ-E01943D2 — Performance, load, stress, spike, endurance, and capacity results.
  • USEQ-5ECCFB7E — Resilience, dependency-failure, failover, rollback, roll-forward, and recovery results.
  • USEQ-AE5734B3 — Security scan, code review, threat-validation, and penetration-test results.
  • USEQ-B39689E7 — SBOM, license report, build provenance, artifact signatures, and attestation evidence.
  • USEQ-0C482ED0 — Infrastructure, network, DNS, certificate, secrets, and production-configuration review.
  • USEQ-C3A340EE — Backup, restoration, disaster-recovery, and continuity evidence.
  • USEQ-4A35B528 — Incident-response, on-call, alerting, runbook, and communications drill evidence.
  • USEQ-F475A3F9 — Monitoring, dashboard, synthetic-check, logging, audit, and telemetry review.
  • USEQ-0DBF3D1F — Third-party risk, contract, subprocessor, and continuity review.
  • USEQ-41AB3A61 — Open defect, risk, and exception registers.
  • USEQ-8C3A67DF — Every exception's owner, impact, compensating control, monitoring, remediation plan, and expiry.
  • USEQ-68373154 — Deployment, rollback or roll-forward, and post-deployment validation plans.
  • USEQ-291D1CF9 — Required approvals, sign-offs, and final decision rationale.

Corpus Maintenance and Versioning

Consolidated from quality standards/00-core/08-corpus-maintenance-and-versioning.md; 20 non-duplicative controls.

Maintenance controls

  • USEQ-96C0CF6A — Assign a corpus owner and qualified maintainers across product, engineering, UX, security, privacy, data, quality, delivery, operations, and legal domains.
  • USEQ-8A990F83 — Review the corpus at least annually and after major standards revisions.
  • USEQ-8B838859 — Review it after every material incident, audit finding, penetration-test finding, accessibility failure, privacy harm, safety event, or near miss.
  • USEQ-E5AB0C75 — Review it when entering a new jurisdiction, sector, user population, deployment model, or contractual regime.
  • USEQ-56E10E2D — Review it after adding new sensitive data, identity, payment, AI, device, physical-control, or high-impact functionality.
  • USEQ-692CA8B7 — Track authoritative standards and mark published, amended, withdrawn, superseded, and draft status accurately.
  • USEQ-0A48A6ED — Do not replace current published baselines with drafts unless a documented transition decision requires early adoption.
  • USEQ-1CD7806F — Preserve historical corpus versions and the exact version used for each release or audit.
  • USEQ-6074CE61 — Record every added, changed, moved, or retired control with rationale and owner.
  • USEQ-9F4E9139 — Do not silently weaken controls during consolidation or reorganization.
  • USEQ-87104C15 — Use incidents, defects, user research, support demand, threat intelligence, supplier change, and operational evidence to add or refine controls.
  • USEQ-96ACBB49 — Review duplicate and overlapping controls while preserving standalone usability of category files.
  • USEQ-3726C504 — Validate all Markdown links, headings, checklist syntax, front matter, encoding, and relative paths automatically.
  • USEQ-24066ACE — Validate that every category file contains purpose, applicability, universal controls, evidence expectations, and interpretation boundaries.
  • USEQ-ACB1E213 — Search for accidental secrets, personal data, internal URLs, and proprietary information before publication.
  • USEQ-D3AEAB87 — Review framework, vendor, language, and platform references and keep universal files technology-neutral.
  • USEQ-61E97483 — Place genuinely technology-specific controls only in clearly conditional modules.
  • USEQ-C6F40249 — Measure corpus use, control ambiguity, Not Applicable patterns, exception recurrence, and escaped defects.
  • USEQ-8CB08DFC — Retire obsolete controls only after confirming the risk or requirement no longer exists.
  • USEQ-27EF115F — Publish release notes and a migration guide for material corpus changes.

Governance, Ownership, and Risk

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/01-governance-ownership-and-risk.md; 19 non-duplicative controls.

Ownership

  • USEQ-8C84BDA1 — Every production service has named business and engineering owners.
  • USEQ-C8627A8D — Every third-party integration, dashboard, alert, runbook, scheduled job, and background process has an owner.
  • USEQ-2F823834 — Ownership remains valid during leave, holidays, and personnel changes.
  • USEQ-8272E813 — Escalation paths include primary, secondary, management, security, privacy/legal, and provider contacts.
  • USEQ-170D2EA2 — Offboarding and role changes remove or adjust access promptly.
  • USEQ-17D2A81C — Ownership records are periodically reviewed.

Risk assessment

  • USEQ-6B39A8A1 — Classify confidentiality, integrity, availability, privacy, financial, fraud, safety, regulatory, contractual, reputation, and customer-trust impact.
  • USEQ-21A06C7A — Identify external attackers, abusive users, insiders, compromised accounts, bots, automated agents, social engineering, and accidental failure sources.
  • USEQ-ACE196FE — Identify foreseeable misuse and abuse, not only intended use.
  • USEQ-4B9CB799 — Give every risk an owner, likelihood, impact, treatment, evidence, and review date.
  • USEQ-0B8D7893 — Record accepted residual risks and the authorized people who accept them.
  • USEQ-786705B4 — Verify that launch scope remains within the organization's approved risk appetite.
  • USEQ-9843CD0A — Ensure exceptions expire and compensating controls are tested.

Control framework

  • USEQ-AFB0927D — Map security controls to a recognized verification standard.
  • USEQ-02B7631F — Map privacy controls to legal and organizational requirements.
  • USEQ-0C8F7443 — Map accessibility controls to the selected conformance target.
  • USEQ-D29A0C99 — Identify and resolve conflicts between product, legal, security, privacy, accessibility, and technical requirements.
  • USEQ-2C632814 — Document resolutions, tradeoffs, and approvals.
  • USEQ-DDBA1140 — Periodically confirm the selected control level still matches application risk.

Third-Party and Supplier Readiness

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/02-third-party-and-supplier-readiness.md; 15 non-duplicative controls.

Universal controls

  • USEQ-4246F390 — Record each provider's purpose, owner, data access, permissions, regions, subprocessors, and criticality.
  • USEQ-AAED2E02 — Security, privacy, resilience, accessibility, and compliance due diligence is proportionate to risk.
  • USEQ-9C004476 — Contracts cover service levels, security, permitted data use, incident notification, deletion, portability, audit, and termination.
  • USEQ-0D759FDC — Provider credentials and permissions follow least privilege.
  • USEQ-FC267359 — Integration secrets are rotatable and revocable.
  • USEQ-D669D379 — Provider quotas, rate limits, concurrency limits, regional limits, and support commitments are understood.
  • USEQ-DE1C021A — Provider availability and recovery commitments align with product objectives.
  • USEQ-5DA6E2FF — Provider webhooks and callbacks are authenticated and replay-protected.
  • USEQ-FBBA350E — Breaking-change and incident notifications reach an accountable owner.
  • USEQ-8FC152BB — Provider outages, delays, malformed responses, throttling, and partial failures are tested.
  • USEQ-FC8F0D82 — Provider data-use and contract changes are monitored.
  • USEQ-DB18DC98 — A replacement, exit, continuity, and data-export plan exists for critical providers.
  • USEQ-01D417C3 — The application can identify records and users affected by a provider incident.
  • USEQ-615B275E — Provider status and escalation contacts are included in runbooks.
  • USEQ-B009F0F4 — No provider can silently expand data collection or processing beyond approved behavior.

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/03-legal-regulatory-and-contractual-applicability.md; 27 non-duplicative controls.

Universal controls

  • USEQ-8211B7E2 — Identify applicable privacy, data-protection, cybersecurity, breach-notification, and data-localization laws.
  • USEQ-029FDBE7 — Identify accessibility laws, public-sector rules, procurement requirements, and sector-specific accessibility duties.
  • USEQ-6B2941CB — Identify consumer-protection, unfair-practice, pricing, subscription, renewal, cancellation, refund, and complaint requirements.
  • USEQ-532689B4 — Identify marketing, advertising, email, SMS, telemarketing, tracking, and consent requirements.
  • USEQ-1364FDC7 — Identify payment, banking, financial-service, insurance, securities, tax, invoicing, currency, and marketplace requirements.
  • USEQ-846F99B4 — Identify healthcare, education, employment, housing, government, critical-infrastructure, and other sector requirements.
  • USEQ-3C9DE828 — Identify children's privacy, age-assurance, age-appropriate-design, and child-safety requirements.
  • USEQ-2FF57224 — Identify identity-verification, anti-fraud, anti-money-laundering, sanctions, export-control, and restricted-country obligations.
  • USEQ-F29992F2 — Identify record-retention, legal-hold, evidence-preservation, and lawful-request obligations.
  • USEQ-F499A92F — Identify international-transfer and data-residency requirements.
  • USEQ-BC302091 — Identify content, intellectual-property, copyright, moderation, intermediary, and platform obligations.
  • USEQ-BD48566C — Identify algorithmic-decision, automated-decision, AI, transparency, explanation, human-review, and appeal requirements.
  • USEQ-45790745 — Identify contractual and customer-specific security, privacy, availability, audit, and notification requirements.
  • USEQ-A6E04178 — Terms of service match actual behavior.
  • USEQ-685C66D7 — Privacy and cookie notices match actual data and tracking behavior.
  • USEQ-9FBCC7DE — Acceptable-use, content, moderation, and safety policies are enforceable and communicated.
  • USEQ-EC4D34E4 — Trademarks, media, data sets, fonts, models, and other content have appropriate rights.
  • USEQ-CAA051A6 — Security, compliance, privacy, sustainability, accessibility, and performance claims are accurate and supportable.
  • USEQ-4C0378A1 — Required contact, company, pricing, cancellation, complaint, and regulatory information is displayed.
  • USEQ-96B1F594 — Renewal, review, filing, audit, and reporting deadlines are tracked.

Frequently triggered regulatory modules

  • USEQ-903DD079Payments: determine actual payment-security scope and apply the current applicable payment-card or financial-security standard.
  • USEQ-7690E19BHealth information: determine whether health-information laws or contracts apply and implement required administrative, physical, and technical safeguards.
  • USEQ-4CF7E38BChildren: determine whether the product is directed to children or knows it has child users and apply parental-consent, minimization, advertising, design, safety, and deletion requirements.
  • USEQ-63BBB657Accessibility: determine whether regional accessibility laws, public-sector rules, procurement requirements, or sector requirements apply.
  • USEQ-64DF55C0Financial services: determine licensing, disclosures, suitability, anti-fraud, recordkeeping, customer-protection, and transaction-monitoring obligations.
  • USEQ-C3784FD4Employment, housing, education, credit, insurance, and essential services: determine whether nondiscrimination, fairness, explanation, appeal, recordkeeping, and human-review obligations apply.
  • USEQ-224DF94FGovernment and critical infrastructure: determine whether additional security, hosting, accessibility, records, resilience, and supply-chain obligations apply.

Quality Management and Continual Improvement

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/04-quality-management-and-continual-improvement.md; 55 non-duplicative controls.

Governance and lifecycle controls

  • USEQ-0897EF0F — Define the category scope, intended outcomes, boundaries, stakeholders, users, and affected systems.
  • USEQ-F828BDE3 — Assign one accountable owner and identify all contributing and reviewing roles.
  • USEQ-7FE46690 — Inventory the artifacts, interfaces, data, dependencies, suppliers, environments, and lifecycle stages in scope.
  • USEQ-716AACBA — Translate quality goals into explicit, testable requirements and acceptance criteria.
  • USEQ-F79AAA15 — Identify legal, contractual, security, privacy, accessibility, safety, reliability, and business constraints.
  • USEQ-6365A464 — Identify foreseeable misuse, failure modes, edge conditions, and conflicting stakeholder needs.
  • USEQ-770D6E54 — Record material assumptions and validate them with evidence before relying on them.
  • USEQ-0D80749F — Record material design decisions, alternatives, trade-offs, consequences, and reversal conditions.
  • USEQ-06344248 — Prefer the least complex solution that satisfies current evidenced requirements and preserves necessary evolution paths.
  • USEQ-C7901DA7 — Maintain traceability from goals and risks through decisions, implementation, verification, deployment, and operational evidence.
  • USEQ-E075330B — Apply independent review proportionate to impact and prevent authors from self-approving material controls.
  • USEQ-C7D1EC67 — Automate repeatable checks where automation is reliable, and retain human evaluation where judgment or user context is required.
  • USEQ-3B2B2AC9 — Test normal, negative, boundary, concurrency, failure, recovery, upgrade, rollback, and misuse behavior as applicable.
  • USEQ-9F30EF3C — Use production-representative data shape, scale, topology, configuration, and dependency behavior for material verification.
  • USEQ-6D6113E1 — Measure outcomes and quality attributes rather than relying only on activity, output, or vanity metrics.
  • USEQ-C37654F3 — Make failures observable, diagnosable, containable, recoverable, and learnable.
  • USEQ-EC2F36AC — Document operating procedures, limitations, ownership, support paths, and lifecycle expectations.
  • USEQ-C60E9C67 — Define deprecation, migration, retention, archival, and retirement behavior before those paths become urgent.
  • USEQ-69216AAA — Review the controls after material change, incident, audit finding, user harm, supplier change, or new evidence.
  • USEQ-08BC8F27 — Convert recurring defects, support demand, security findings, and operational toil into permanent systemic improvements.

Category-specific universal rules

  • USEQ-23D52699 — Establish a quality policy aligned with customer outcomes, safety, security, privacy, accessibility, reliability, and business objectives.
  • USEQ-740272E6 — Define measurable quality objectives at organization, portfolio, product, service, and release levels.
  • USEQ-DA6F3EA5 — Ensure quality objectives do not conflict with incentives that reward speed or output at the expense of outcomes.
  • USEQ-B73EE86B — Define process owners, process inputs, expected outcomes, controls, records, and improvement mechanisms.
  • USEQ-715E3556 — Tailor processes explicitly to context without silently removing required outcomes.
  • USEQ-E77901AD — Use prevention and early feedback before relying on downstream inspection.
  • USEQ-9A8916C2 — Integrate quality planning into discovery, requirements, architecture, implementation, verification, release, operation, and retirement.
  • USEQ-73C6FD52 — Use independent assurance for high-impact claims and controls.
  • USEQ-496084CD — Analyze escapes, rework, incidents, complaints, support demand, and near misses as quality-system signals.
  • USEQ-5BC79E55 — Distinguish common-cause systemic problems from isolated special-cause events.
  • USEQ-B5A8BFB6 — Prioritize corrective action according to user harm, risk, recurrence, and systemic reach.
  • USEQ-CF27C8CE — Verify corrective actions for effectiveness rather than closing them when work is merely completed.
  • USEQ-6B1C466A — Prevent local optimizations from degrading end-to-end product or service quality.
  • USEQ-587925A5 — Maintain control of nonconforming work products and prevent accidental release or reuse.
  • USEQ-4246E9DC — Use calibrated tools, test assets, data sets, and environments where measurement validity depends on them.
  • USEQ-2AFCA02A — Review supplier quality and inherited controls as part of the same quality system.
  • USEQ-277CEB44 — Conduct periodic management review using evidence, trends, unresolved risk, customer feedback, and improvement results.
  • USEQ-225D52E9 — Preserve organizational learning so recurring failures do not reset with personnel or team changes.

Required evidence

  • USEQ-928743A4 — Retain an approved scope and applicability record.
  • USEQ-2CD5DD6D — Retain requirements and acceptance criteria linked to risks and intended outcomes.
  • USEQ-0BC431C9 — Retain decision records and review approvals for material choices.
  • USEQ-45C1DDB5 — Retain automated and manual verification results tied to the exact assessed revision.
  • USEQ-48BBA3DE — Retain representative examples of successful, failed, boundary, and recovery behavior.
  • USEQ-E1B67CDC — Retain current metrics, thresholds, trends, and the rationale for each threshold.
  • USEQ-321D7565 — Retain an open-defect and residual-risk register with owners and target dates.
  • USEQ-3358CD08 — Retain evidence that temporary exceptions and compensating controls are monitored and expire.
  • USEQ-397DD8D0 — Retain operational evidence showing the control continues to work after deployment.
  • USEQ-FB14A009 — Retain lessons and corrective actions from incidents, escapes, regressions, and near misses.

Category no-go conditions

  • USEQ-A1AD3791 — Do not approve the category when a critical requirement lacks objective evidence.
  • USEQ-8A113D59 — Do not use checklist completion percentages to offset a material unresolved risk.
  • USEQ-9CC0C0B9 — Do not accept a control merely because a tool, supplier, framework, or platform claims to provide it.
  • USEQ-7D0D9C8E — Do not mark a control Not Applicable solely because it is difficult, expensive, owned elsewhere, or not yet implemented.
  • USEQ-6993212D — Do not proceed when the team cannot detect, contain, recover from, or communicate a foreseeable high-impact failure.
  • USEQ-961EF318 — Quality objectives are undefined, contradictory, or impossible to measure.
  • USEQ-F33B64FF — Known systemic defects recur without an effective corrective-action program.

Engineering Governance and Decision Rights

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/05-engineering-governance-and-decision-rights.md; 15 non-duplicative controls.

Category-specific universal rules

  • USEQ-41CEC06B — Define which decisions are centralized, delegated, advisory, or prohibited.
  • USEQ-35C12A25 — Assign decision rights to roles with sufficient competence, authority, independence, and context.
  • USEQ-A56E3EB0 — Separate decision authority from personal status, seniority, or tool ownership.
  • USEQ-2048A133 — Define mandatory engineering guardrails and the risk basis for each guardrail.
  • USEQ-EA86F0CC — Publish escalation paths for conflicts between product, engineering, security, privacy, reliability, accessibility, legal, and commercial goals.
  • USEQ-573E2FC1 — Require material decisions to state the problem, context, options, evidence, trade-offs, decision, owner, date, and review trigger.
  • USEQ-4D7CD9DF — Make reversible decisions quickly while applying more rigor to irreversible or high-cost decisions.
  • USEQ-41A69859 — Require affected stakeholders to be consulted before decisions that transfer risk or operational burden to them.
  • USEQ-31ADB2B3 — Prevent architecture boards and review bodies from becoming unaccountable bottlenecks.
  • USEQ-1C45E26D — Ensure exceptions identify the exact control waived, duration, compensating controls, owner, and exit plan.
  • USEQ-4E007EF6 — Review decision outcomes and retire decisions whose assumptions no longer hold.
  • USEQ-4384C947 — Make governance artifacts discoverable and understandable to the people expected to follow them.
  • USEQ-5657213E — Ensure emergency decision paths preserve auditability and receive retrospective review.
  • USEQ-FED54377 — Define how teams challenge unsafe decisions without retaliation.
  • USEQ-77A6DDD9 — Measure governance by decision quality, risk outcomes, and flow—not meeting volume or document count.

Project, Program, and Portfolio Management

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/06-project-program-and-portfolio-management.md; 15 non-duplicative controls.

Category-specific universal rules

  • USEQ-0B4B4DFD — Connect every initiative to an explicit user, business, compliance, risk-reduction, or platform outcome.
  • USEQ-AA4F038D — Define scope, non-scope, assumptions, constraints, dependencies, milestones, acceptance criteria, and completion conditions.
  • USEQ-9F8B6548 — Use outcome-based funding and review rather than treating initial estimates as immutable commitments.
  • USEQ-DF8B2B5D — Maintain an integrated dependency map across products, teams, suppliers, data, infrastructure, and regulatory work.
  • USEQ-0BE4C2D3 — Identify the critical path and critical chain without hiding uncertainty behind single-point estimates.
  • USEQ-F2229F87 — Represent uncertainty with ranges, scenarios, confidence, and explicit assumptions.
  • USEQ-9BAB8E9B — Reserve capacity for defects, security, reliability, maintenance, learning, and unplanned work.
  • USEQ-511069A8 — Prevent portfolio overcommitment from making every initiative simultaneously urgent.
  • USEQ-049681CB — Define benefit owners and measure whether expected benefits are realized after delivery.
  • USEQ-EA0E51DC — Stop or reshape initiatives when evidence invalidates the original case.
  • USEQ-B7629D08 — Coordinate cross-team interface, migration, release, and operational readiness obligations.
  • USEQ-BFDEE280 — Use transparent change control for material scope, schedule, cost, quality, or risk changes.
  • USEQ-2E9C12E9 — Treat unresolved staffing or skill gaps as delivery risks, not individual performance problems.
  • USEQ-9BF0B2DD — Ensure project closure includes handover, operational acceptance, documentation, residual risk, and lessons learned.
  • USEQ-55341909 — Avoid rewarding deadline compliance when it produces hidden quality, security, or sustainability debt.

Engineering Measurement and Metrics

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/07-engineering-measurement-and-metrics.md; 15 non-duplicative controls.

Category-specific universal rules

  • USEQ-DB947847 — Begin with a decision or information need before selecting a metric.
  • USEQ-DF84913E — Define each metric's construct, population, unit, method, source, frequency, owner, limitations, and intended decisions.
  • USEQ-F1BEE0D8 — Validate that a metric measures the intended property rather than an easy proxy.
  • USEQ-BFBA2F5B — Use balanced measures spanning outcomes, flow, quality, reliability, security, sustainability, and human factors.
  • USEQ-1163E0B6 — Use distributions and percentiles where averages hide important variation.
  • USEQ-2662F4B7 — Segment data when aggregate results can conceal harmed users, devices, regions, tenants, or cohorts.
  • USEQ-163BE262 — Define confidence, uncertainty, sampling, missing-data, and measurement-error treatment.
  • USEQ-7598EA63 — Protect measurement systems against manipulation, gaming, selection bias, and survivorship bias.
  • USEQ-5AAC4687 — Avoid using team-level system metrics as simplistic individual performance scores.
  • USEQ-13A8CCE3 — Review metric behavior after process or tooling changes that alter collection semantics.
  • USEQ-22853BEF — Establish baselines and distinguish natural variation from meaningful change.
  • USEQ-9282AB20 — Predefine success, guardrail, stop, and rollback thresholds for experiments and launches.
  • USEQ-82522805 — Preserve raw evidence and transformation lineage sufficient to reproduce reported values.
  • USEQ-1C341AE4 — Retire metrics that no longer inform decisions or create harmful incentives.
  • USEQ-3DAEC856 — Pair quantitative evidence with qualitative user and operator evidence where context matters.

People, Competence, Culture, and Sustainable Work

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/08-people-competence-culture-and-sustainable-work.md; 15 non-duplicative controls.

Category-specific universal rules

  • USEQ-CC59B784 — Define competency expectations for each material engineering, product, design, security, privacy, data, quality, and operations role.
  • USEQ-1BE6DBB2 — Assess competency using demonstrated outcomes and supervised practice rather than attendance alone.
  • USEQ-77B89A84 — Provide training before assigning high-impact responsibilities.
  • USEQ-7114A125 — Ensure reviewers have relevant expertise and sufficient time to review.
  • USEQ-805EACEA — Use pairing, mentoring, rotation, and documentation to reduce single-person dependencies.
  • USEQ-6062519D — Maintain succession and backup coverage for critical systems and responsibilities.
  • USEQ-D28F8B74 — Create psychologically safe channels for raising defects, risk, uncertainty, and ethical concerns.
  • USEQ-C1D6C65C — Prohibit retaliation for stopping unsafe work or reporting material risk in good faith.
  • USEQ-AE14AF0D — Avoid chronic overtime, interrupted leave, and unsustainable on-call as routine capacity strategies.
  • USEQ-866D6154 — Treat excessive toil and cognitive load as system defects to reduce.
  • USEQ-4DB71087 — Design team boundaries and ownership to minimize coordination cost while preserving end-to-end accountability.
  • USEQ-5F523DA1 — Ensure incentives reward quality, collaboration, learning, and customer outcomes rather than heroics and local output.
  • USEQ-456D1187 — Include accessibility, privacy, security, reliability, and incident skills in role-appropriate learning paths.
  • USEQ-7584EFCD — Review access promptly when people join, change roles, take leave, or depart.
  • USEQ-FBBC8C19 — Capture critical tacit knowledge before reorganizations, outsourcing, or retirement.

Ethics and Responsible Technology

Consolidated from quality standards/01-governance/09-ethics-and-responsible-technology.md; 15 non-duplicative controls.

Category-specific universal rules

  • USEQ-5A014C1A — Identify people and communities who can be affected, including non-users and vulnerable groups.
  • USEQ-338D038D — Assess intended benefits, foreseeable harms, misuse, power imbalances, and unequal distribution of risk.
  • USEQ-1216601A — Avoid collecting, inferring, or exposing sensitive information without a necessary and justified purpose.
  • USEQ-00419A24 — Avoid manipulative, coercive, deceptive, addictive, or exploitative interaction patterns.
  • USEQ-63731FF6 — Provide meaningful transparency about consequential automated or policy-driven outcomes.
  • USEQ-8D2D4788 — Provide human review, appeal, correction, and redress where decisions can materially affect people.
  • USEQ-C9E9ADAC — Test for systematically different quality or harm across relevant groups and contexts.
  • USEQ-219A351E — Do not use protected or sensitive attributes as proxies without lawful, ethical, and evidenced justification.
  • USEQ-3C567287 — Limit surveillance, monitoring, scoring, and behavioral influence to proportionate purposes.
  • USEQ-0F61741E — Protect user autonomy through reversible choices, clear defaults, and genuine refusal paths.
  • USEQ-4A92C813 — Define unacceptable uses and enforce them technically and contractually where practical.
  • USEQ-55927854 — Establish independent escalation for conflicts between commercial objectives and human welfare.
  • USEQ-7858A9FB — Include environmental and labor impacts in major technology and supplier decisions.
  • USEQ-A7CFBEC2 — Reassess impact as usage, scale, context, data, models, and downstream integrations change.
  • USEQ-46335AA9 — Stop or constrain a capability when harms cannot be reduced below approved tolerance.

Final Gap Closure — Governance, Acquisition, Automated Decisions, and Rights

Consolidated from final consolidated corpus/01-governance-product-requirements-risk-ethics-lifecycle.md#Final Gap Closure — Governance, Acquisition, Automated Decisions, and Rights; 215 non-duplicative controls.

Compliance and obligations management

  • USEQ-0A917506 — Maintain one authoritative register of applicable laws, regulations, contracts, standards, licenses, policies, certifications, customer commitments, and internal obligations.
  • USEQ-FC410330 — Record the jurisdiction, authority, scope, effective date, owner, interpretation, evidence, review date, and change source for every obligation.
  • USEQ-228A7EAC — Translate each applicable obligation into testable product, process, operational, documentation, and evidence requirements.
  • USEQ-0A0A5D07 — Distinguish mandatory obligations from voluntary commitments, guidance, aspirations, and marketing claims.
  • USEQ-5826CC12 — Resolve conflicts among legal, contractual, ethical, security, privacy, accessibility, safety, and product requirements through documented authorized decisions.
  • USEQ-0A75AF7B — Monitor official sources for amendments, enforcement guidance, court decisions, regulator interpretations, and transition deadlines that can change applicability.
  • USEQ-4BD7C569 — Reassess obligations before entering a new market, serving a new user population, processing a new data type, changing a supplier, or materially changing functionality.
  • USEQ-899D534D — Ensure compliance owners have sufficient authority, independence, competence, resources, and access to decision-makers.
  • USEQ-E5464005 — Prevent commercial or delivery pressure from suppressing a material compliance concern.
  • USEQ-E49A534A — Require qualified review when an obligation is ambiguous, high impact, or outside the team's competence.
  • USEQ-33C53EA1 — Link obligations to requirements, risks, controls, tests, operating procedures, records, owners, and release decisions.
  • USEQ-56A86581 — Verify that controls operate in the actual production context rather than only existing in policy documents.
  • USEQ-68C68A3D — Maintain evidence of compliance decisions and the factual basis used at the time.
  • USEQ-61C0266E — Track nonconformities, corrective actions, due dates, owners, effectiveness checks, and recurrence.
  • USEQ-61985D0A — Escalate repeated or systemic nonconformity beyond the team that created it.
  • USEQ-4F97A2C6 — Define which nonconformities block release, require customer notification, or trigger incident response.
  • USEQ-2E9F63DE — Review whether accepted exceptions remain legally and contractually permissible.
  • USEQ-E34BC22A — Ensure temporary waivers expire automatically and cannot become permanent through inattention.
  • USEQ-A98DF5A6 — Verify that customer-specific commitments are reflected in tenant, region, configuration, support, and reporting behavior.
  • USEQ-39F64583 — Prevent unsupported certifications, seals, compliance labels, security claims, privacy claims, accessibility claims, and quality claims.
  • USEQ-8BAFBF7E — State the exact product, service, location, version, period, and control scope covered by every assurance claim.
  • USEQ-DE933B4A — Track certification and audit surveillance dates, evidence windows, exclusions, dependencies, and renewal actions.
  • USEQ-D673A4A5 — Ensure changes cannot move the product outside a certified or contracted scope without review.
  • USEQ-EDCF9DA1 — Maintain a controlled process for regulator, auditor, customer, and lawful-authority requests.
  • USEQ-214C3BC6 — Protect privilege, confidentiality, personal data, trade secrets, and investigation integrity when responding to requests.
  • USEQ-1ECFF549 — Record why an obligation was judged Not Applicable and have the judgment reviewed by an authorized person.
  • USEQ-EBBC0B9E — Reopen applicability judgments when facts, interpretations, product scope, or law change.
  • USEQ-D2C209FC — Measure control effectiveness and outcome quality rather than counting policies, training sessions, or completed forms alone.
  • USEQ-5AFB222A — Test compliance processes through sampling, walkthroughs, incident simulations, and independent review.
  • USEQ-D4694365 — Provide a confidential path for reporting suspected noncompliance and protect reporters from retaliation.
  • USEQ-EB301D83 — Preserve required records for the applicable period and dispose of them defensibly when the obligation ends.
  • USEQ-F60CED4C — Ensure compliance evidence remains understandable and retrievable after personnel, vendor, or technology changes.
  • USEQ-EF95F68C — Include compliance impacts in architecture decisions, backlog prioritization, procurement, release planning, and retirement.
  • USEQ-517D13D7 — Treat supplier-operated obligations as shared responsibilities and verify the supplier's evidence rather than assuming transfer of accountability.
  • USEQ-648076DD — Review the compliance management system after material incidents, enforcement actions, audit findings, or recurring customer complaints.

Acquisition, supply, outsourcing, and exit governance

  • USEQ-C097977F — Define the business capability, outcomes, constraints, risks, data, interfaces, service levels, and acceptance criteria before selecting a supplier or product.
  • USEQ-E8FAD9D8 — Compare build, buy, reuse, partner, and retire options using lifecycle value, risk, reversibility, opportunity cost, and organizational capability.
  • USEQ-AD81EAAC — Include migration, integration, operation, support, security, privacy, accessibility, continuity, and exit costs in acquisition decisions.
  • USEQ-53949496 — Assess whether the supplier's financial, operational, security, quality, legal, and staffing capacity is proportionate to criticality.
  • USEQ-37920856 — Identify fourth parties and other subcontractors that can materially affect the service or data.
  • USEQ-32E592BA — Evaluate concentration risk where multiple critical capabilities depend on one provider, region, control plane, identity system, or corporate group.
  • USEQ-34730C2F — Define contractual ownership and permitted use of source code, binaries, configuration, data, metadata, telemetry, models, prompts, documentation, and derived outputs.
  • USEQ-76A225D3 — Define which party is responsible for defects, vulnerabilities, incidents, accessibility barriers, data errors, legal requests, and customer support.
  • USEQ-15770275 — Include measurable service levels and service-level remedies that reflect real user and business impact.
  • USEQ-330DBEE1 — Specify security, privacy, accessibility, quality, continuity, records, audit, and incident-notification obligations in enforceable terms.
  • USEQ-9DE72FA9 — Require timely notice of material changes to ownership, subprocessors, locations, technology, security posture, data use, support, or end-of-life plans.
  • USEQ-CBCD7DAA — Preserve rights to obtain sufficient evidence, audit reports, test results, architecture information, and incident details.
  • USEQ-49502674 — Ensure confidentiality terms do not prevent necessary security disclosure, regulatory reporting, or customer notification.
  • USEQ-7A7A29CE — Define vulnerability disclosure, remediation targets, emergency coordination, and customer advisory responsibilities.
  • USEQ-3C3DC5B8 — Define data return, export format, completeness, integrity, metadata, provenance, and deletion obligations at termination.
  • USEQ-033D8FA9 — Require deletion evidence for data, credentials, backups, replicas, caches, support copies, and subprocessors where applicable.
  • USEQ-7A559BF6 — Define portability for identities, permissions, configuration, workflows, schemas, integrations, keys, logs, and historical records.
  • USEQ-CA6C9422 — Avoid contractual or technical lock-in that makes safe exit economically or operationally infeasible without explicit acceptance.
  • USEQ-7BC25239 — Identify proprietary extensions and document the consequence of losing them during migration.
  • USEQ-B97EFA06 — Require open, documented, or independently implementable interfaces when interoperability and exitability are material.
  • USEQ-123B91B1 — Define source escrow, continuity licensing, documentation access, or equivalent safeguards when supplier failure would be unacceptable.
  • USEQ-6C97F8ED — Verify that escrowed or transferred material is complete, current, buildable, deployable, maintainable, and legally usable.
  • USEQ-AEBAE6E8 — Define transition assistance, knowledge transfer, overlap periods, support continuity, and key-person availability.
  • USEQ-237A0006 — Test exports, backups, migration tooling, and alternate-provider integration before an emergency forces their use.
  • USEQ-83E0FB27 — Maintain an exit plan for each critical supplier from the start of the relationship.
  • USEQ-6AB53D5A — Assign an exit owner and estimate time, cost, dependencies, data movement, customer impact, and residual obligations.
  • USEQ-E6A9CCF0 — Identify supplier-provided controls that would disappear during exit and replace them before cutover.
  • USEQ-C8B933AD — Prevent test or evaluation access from becoming unreviewed production dependency.
  • USEQ-57E8F571 — Require formal acceptance against agreed criteria before treating acquired software or services as production ready.
  • USEQ-C11220A0 — Separate supplier demonstration from independent verification using representative workloads and failure conditions.
  • USEQ-B1DA6120 — Verify licensing quantities, use rights, geographic restrictions, support rights, and renewal conditions before deployment.
  • USEQ-02A1C0FF — Track notice periods, price changes, minimum commitments, automatic renewals, and termination windows.
  • USEQ-B6B75132 — Prevent procurement incentives from rewarding low initial price while hiding long-term risk or switching cost.
  • USEQ-F0EB40C4 — Define governance for supplier-requested emergency changes and exceptions.
  • USEQ-265DA109 — Review supplier performance using outcomes, incidents, risk trends, roadmap delivery, support quality, and corrective-action effectiveness.
  • USEQ-14A323CB — Escalate chronic supplier underperformance and maintain objective replacement triggers.
  • USEQ-CA5F0120 — Ensure supplier personnel access uses individual identities, least privilege, time limits, logging, and prompt revocation.
  • USEQ-C744DA1F — Remove supplier access, integrations, credentials, certificates, routes, accounts, and data when the relationship ends.
  • USEQ-DD784EF2 — Preserve contractual and technical evidence needed for disputes, audits, investigations, and transition.
  • USEQ-B4C136B8 — Reassess critical suppliers after acquisition, merger, restructuring, leadership change, breach, sanctions exposure, or material service degradation.
  • USEQ-66028C4E — Document the residual risks accepted when a supplier cannot satisfy a required control.
  • USEQ-DD621797 — Ensure the risk owner accepting a supplier exception is independent of the commercial incentive to proceed.

Organizational change, adoption, and benefits realization

  • USEQ-7D97FA29 — Identify every group whose work, rights, incentives, responsibilities, workload, or outcomes will change.
  • USEQ-F4BFF6A0 — Involve affected users, operators, support teams, administrators, and downstream partners early enough to influence design.
  • USEQ-7A6C75E2 — Document the current process, target process, transition states, retained exceptions, and retirement conditions.
  • USEQ-BD17C161 — Distinguish technical deployment from successful adoption and verified benefit realization.
  • USEQ-F637AD14 — Define adoption outcomes, behavioral indicators, user outcomes, business outcomes, safety indicators, and failure criteria before launch.
  • USEQ-B8EE5089 — Establish baseline measurements before changing the system or process.
  • USEQ-C4685A7E — Validate that the change addresses the actual problem rather than merely introducing new technology.
  • USEQ-183A85DE — Identify incentives that can cause gaming, unsafe shortcuts, shadow systems, duplicate work, or data-quality degradation.
  • USEQ-9C2558C8 — Assess workload transfer to users, support, operations, security, compliance, and external partners.
  • USEQ-4D532A00 — Ensure automation does not silently shift difficult work or risk to less powerful users.
  • USEQ-AECB2ABF — Provide role-specific training, practice, support, and reference material before affected people are expected to perform new tasks.
  • USEQ-F60A847F — Verify competence through observed performance or assessment rather than attendance alone.
  • USEQ-7908A553 — Provide accessible training and alternatives for different languages, abilities, schedules, locations, and levels of experience.
  • USEQ-871E097A — Pilot changes with representative users, data, volume, constraints, and exception cases.
  • USEQ-6CD7A9F9 — Define safe coexistence between old and new processes during transition.
  • USEQ-05F6D1E7 — Prevent duplicate records, conflicting authorities, and inconsistent decisions while both processes operate.
  • USEQ-88FC79BA — Define which system is authoritative at every transition stage.
  • USEQ-22C353B1 — Provide a supported path for correcting migration, adoption, and training errors.
  • USEQ-7A86F837 — Monitor adoption by user segment to detect exclusion, differential failure, or hidden burden.
  • USEQ-7AE11356 — Collect qualitative feedback as well as usage metrics.
  • USEQ-4FC73955 — Protect users from retaliation for reporting that a change is unsafe, unusable, inaccessible, or ineffective.
  • USEQ-F2A1587B — Maintain a visible decision path for pausing, modifying, narrowing, or reversing the change.
  • USEQ-7B44BE46 — Avoid interpreting forced use as evidence of satisfaction or success.
  • USEQ-2184CE2C — Confirm that users understand changed responsibilities, limits, escalation routes, and consequences.
  • USEQ-36B73F2A — Ensure support capacity matches expected questions, incidents, and transition failures.
  • USEQ-DED02C8E — Update policies, contracts, job aids, controls, dashboards, reports, and audit procedures with the change.
  • USEQ-C4FE996D — Remove obsolete instructions and clearly label temporary transition guidance.
  • USEQ-6CD51BC3 — Measure intended benefits after stabilization and compare them with cost, harm, risk, and displaced work.
  • USEQ-5ECB509F — Investigate benefits that appear only through metric definition changes, excluded populations, or unmeasured downstream costs.
  • USEQ-0C2A39BB — Retire old systems and processes only after legal, operational, data, support, and recovery obligations are satisfied.
  • USEQ-13D789B8 — Preserve access to historical records needed to understand decisions made under the old process.
  • USEQ-5DEBD48E — Capture lessons and update future change assumptions, estimates, training, and rollout methods.
  • USEQ-F54385C8 — Assign an accountable owner for benefits realization beyond the deployment date.
  • USEQ-6A646372 — Close the change only after adoption, outcome, support, control, and retirement criteria are met.

Deterministic automated decisions, rules engines, scoring, and workflow logic

  • USEQ-2A4D03EE — Inventory every automated rule, score, eligibility decision, prioritization, routing decision, threshold, and enforcement action that materially affects people or organizations.
  • USEQ-DE0C89CA — Record the decision purpose, owner, legal basis, ethical rationale, affected populations, inputs, outputs, consequences, and appeal path.
  • USEQ-B989239A — Classify decisions by potential harm, reversibility, scale, sensitivity, and degree of human reliance.
  • USEQ-BA4A6745 — Require stronger review, evidence, monitoring, and human oversight as decision impact increases.
  • USEQ-FA2A720B — Define the authoritative source and version for every rule and decision table.
  • USEQ-0518839E — Prevent undocumented business rules from existing only in code, spreadsheets, individual memory, or vendor configuration.
  • USEQ-A9E124F3 — Translate policy language into unambiguous executable logic with reviewed examples and counterexamples.
  • USEQ-7EA42112 — Record ambiguities, discretionary areas, conflicts, exceptions, and precedence among rules.
  • USEQ-CC7A27FE — Make rule effective dates, expiry dates, jurisdiction, product scope, and population scope explicit.
  • USEQ-5BF321CF — Ensure historical decisions can be reconstructed using the rules, data, configuration, and time context in force at the time.
  • USEQ-D0AF7A75 — Validate every input for accuracy, completeness, timeliness, provenance, semantic meaning, and permitted use.
  • USEQ-CE3B9271 — Define behavior for missing, disputed, stale, inconsistent, or low-confidence input.
  • USEQ-7881AC46 — Prevent proxies from defeating legal, ethical, fairness, or purpose limitations.
  • USEQ-A1EF5F3D — Test rules across representative demographic, geographic, linguistic, accessibility, and socioeconomic groups where outcomes can differ.
  • USEQ-15661B6F — Test boundary values and combinations near thresholds for disproportionate or unstable effects.
  • USEQ-69F2B791 — Detect feedback loops in which earlier automated outcomes shape future inputs and reinforce error or disadvantage.
  • USEQ-05AA60BA — Evaluate whether a threshold creates cliff effects that should be replaced by review, graduated handling, or uncertainty disclosure.
  • USEQ-85E43B93 — Provide understandable reasons for consequential outcomes at a level appropriate to affected users and reviewers.
  • USEQ-3D5B49D0 — Distinguish an explanation of the actual decision from generic policy text.
  • USEQ-E94AE5FB — Avoid exposing security-sensitive details while still providing meaningful reason and redress.
  • USEQ-ECA2F700 — Provide a timely, accessible, and effective path to challenge, correct, and appeal consequential decisions.
  • USEQ-E6116080 — Ensure reviewers can change an outcome and are not evaluated solely on agreement with automation.
  • USEQ-AAE859CB — Prevent automation bias by presenting uncertainty, conflicting evidence, limitations, and alternatives.
  • USEQ-EE4F8C75 — Define when human review is mandatory and what competence, authority, time, and information the reviewer needs.
  • USEQ-FDC0790E — Record overrides, reasons, outcomes, and patterns without discouraging justified intervention.
  • USEQ-5F638352 — Monitor override rates, appeal success, reversal, complaints, subgroup outcomes, drift, and downstream harm.
  • USEQ-6E4D7B2E — Investigate high disagreement between automated outcomes and expert review.
  • USEQ-16C7AB3F — Separate policy approval from technical implementation approval.
  • USEQ-9C43C510 — Require independent review for rules that affect rights, safety, money, access, employment, education, healthcare, housing, identity, or essential services.
  • USEQ-A3E0DD69 — Version rules, test cases, explanatory text, data mappings, and monitoring together.
  • USEQ-F9A87984 — Use dual control for emergency rule changes with high impact.
  • USEQ-507353D7 — Simulate the population and operational effect of material rule changes before activation.
  • USEQ-DA024B8E — Use phased rollout, shadow evaluation, or retrospective analysis where direct rollout creates avoidable risk.
  • USEQ-C059B588 — Define rollback and remediation for incorrect decisions already made.
  • USEQ-72675725 — Identify every affected record and user when a rule defect is discovered.
  • USEQ-BAD34E15 — Correct downstream systems, notifications, balances, permissions, reports, and derived decisions after remediation.
  • USEQ-A3D3BEAB — Notify affected parties when required or when doing so materially enables correction and trust.
  • USEQ-EF58B259 — Prevent users from manipulating decision inputs beyond intended discretion while avoiding unfair barriers to legitimate correction.
  • USEQ-E0356C82 — Test adversarial gaming, collusion, automation, and economic exploitation of rules.
  • USEQ-4F9E9ECD — Ensure rate limits and fraud controls do not silently create discriminatory or inaccessible outcomes.
  • USEQ-1D490309 — Revalidate rules when source policy, law, population, data collection, product behavior, or operational context changes.
  • USEQ-4892D554 — Retire rules and related data when their purpose or authority ends.
  • USEQ-411D10D5 — Keep a complete audit trail of rule creation, approval, testing, deployment, execution, override, and retirement.
  • USEQ-CC58936A — Publish appropriate transparency about the existence and purpose of material automated decision-making.
  • USEQ-2D7EA97F — Prohibit claims of neutrality or objectivity when the rule embeds policy choices, value judgments, or incomplete data.

Intellectual property, confidential information, and rights provenance

  • USEQ-83CB306E — Identify the owner and permitted uses of every material codebase, library, data set, model, design, document, media asset, brand asset, and generated artifact.
  • USEQ-4161FF42 — Obtain written intellectual-property assignments or licenses from employees, contractors, partners, and contributors where required.
  • USEQ-89CB5A91 — Verify that contributors have authority to provide the material they contribute.
  • USEQ-F8B4E93A — Maintain provenance records for externally sourced code, data, content, models, fonts, images, audio, video, and documentation.
  • USEQ-3F1EA654 — Review license compatibility before combining, distributing, hosting, modifying, or embedding components.
  • USEQ-E687E904 — Fulfil attribution, notice, source-offer, reciprocity, patent, trademark, and redistribution obligations.
  • USEQ-18BB4ACD — Prevent confidential, proprietary, customer, employer, or restricted material from entering repositories or products without authorization.
  • USEQ-1E23B466 — Define rules for employee side projects, prior inventions, open-source contributions, and use of employer resources.
  • USEQ-46E6D74A — Define contribution terms for public and private repositories.
  • USEQ-E4A212F5 — Review contributor license agreements or developer certificates for appropriateness and enforceability.
  • USEQ-B34707EE — Track patents, defensive publications, trademarks, domain names, and other rights material to the product.
  • USEQ-50A7E640 — Avoid asserting patent or trademark rights without qualified review.
  • USEQ-64E5AE64 — Assess freedom-to-operate or infringement risk where the product, market, or contract warrants it.
  • USEQ-53DAE09A — Use clean-room or other controlled development methods when independently reimplementing restricted interfaces or behavior.
  • USEQ-20AD6393 — Preserve evidence that clean-room boundaries and information controls were followed.
  • USEQ-42D1678E — Ensure reverse engineering, interoperability work, scraping, and data acquisition comply with applicable rights and restrictions.
  • USEQ-E49C70F6 — Verify rights to use personal data, licensed data, public data, synthetic data, and derived data for the intended purpose.
  • USEQ-D70EDF93 — Do not assume public availability means unrestricted reuse.
  • USEQ-97C2833E — Verify that training, evaluation, retrieval, analytics, and generated-output uses are covered by appropriate rights.
  • USEQ-29EE3F45 — Define rights and obligations for user-generated content, feedback, support submissions, and uploaded files.
  • USEQ-CC00B307 — Avoid terms that claim broader user-content rights than needed for the service.
  • USEQ-2482AD39 — Provide processes for copyright, trademark, privacy, and other rights complaints.
  • USEQ-FF4BC88F — Prevent takedown processes from being abused without removing effective remedies for legitimate claimants.
  • USEQ-864C229F — Track geographic, field-of-use, time, user-count, device-count, and environment restrictions in licenses.
  • USEQ-D38BB2A8 — Monitor license expiration, renewal, support, and termination dates.
  • USEQ-A6A85301 — Ensure backups, disaster recovery, testing, and archive copies remain within license rights.
  • USEQ-EA6F3090 — Include intellectual-property and data-rights obligations in supplier and acquisition reviews.
  • USEQ-FD996784 — Prevent AI-assisted tools from receiving confidential or restricted material contrary to policy or contract.
  • USEQ-38A675BA — Independently review generated output for unauthorized copying, confidential disclosure, incompatible licensing, and provenance uncertainty.
  • USEQ-9A5356E6 — Preserve trade secrets through access control, confidentiality terms, labeling, training, and reasonable handling practices.
  • USEQ-ACCAC2B8 — Revoke access and recover confidential material during offboarding and supplier termination.
  • USEQ-9A5C1988 — Separate public, internal, confidential, restricted, and customer-owned materials in repositories and documentation systems.
  • USEQ-3B7D73D6 — Review product names, domains, icons, and branding for conflicts before public launch.
  • USEQ-4414E1D1 — Define rights needed for decommissioning, customer export, long-term support, security patching, and legal retention.
  • USEQ-EE05022B — Maintain a response plan for infringement claims, license violations, ownership disputes, and accidental disclosure.
  • USEQ-2967E6ED — Correct notices, distributions, source offers, and customer communications promptly when a rights defect is found.

Speak-up culture, independence, conflicts, and decision integrity

  • USEQ-11CC414E — Provide confidential and accessible channels for reporting quality, safety, security, privacy, accessibility, ethical, legal, and financial concerns.
  • USEQ-FD8476F7 — Prohibit retaliation against people who raise concerns in good faith.
  • USEQ-89CCF5C5 — Allow concerns to bypass the normal management chain when that chain has a conflict or is implicated.
  • USEQ-7C6CF5BB — Define independent escalation to legal, compliance, security, safety, audit, risk, or governing bodies as appropriate.
  • USEQ-22A55748 — Record conflicts of interest for reviewers, approvers, auditors, procurement participants, and risk acceptors.
  • USEQ-7D5BF185 — Recuse or add independent review when a conflict can affect objectivity.
  • USEQ-F42C1888 — Prevent a person from accepting material risk solely to meet a target for which that person is rewarded.
  • USEQ-0081139A — Separate implementation, verification, approval, and audit responsibilities in proportion to risk.
  • USEQ-5D1E5D62 — Ensure independent reviewers receive complete evidence and are not limited to management-selected summaries.
  • USEQ-FB0DCDDA — Protect dissenting technical opinions and record unresolved disagreements in decision records.
  • USEQ-D06298BE — Require decision-makers to address material contrary evidence explicitly.
  • USEQ-866CC7D2 — Do not use consensus pressure to convert unresolved risk into apparent agreement.
  • USEQ-C30D4EE0 — Define stop-work and release-blocking authority for credible high-impact concerns.
  • USEQ-CEECAF90 — Protect the ability to pause unsafe automation, deployment, data use, or customer communication.
  • USEQ-7EE0FA0B — Investigate reports promptly, fairly, confidentially, and with appropriate evidence preservation.
  • USEQ-584CD846 — Communicate outcomes to reporters to the extent legally and operationally possible.
  • USEQ-22119AF5 — Track patterns of ignored warnings, repeated exceptions, near misses, and suppressed defects.
  • USEQ-F8C584BF — Evaluate leaders on truthful risk communication and corrective action, not only delivery speed.
  • USEQ-7BB8745A — Reward prevention, simplification, documentation, mentoring, and reliability work that may not create visible features.
  • USEQ-FA9114A6 — Prohibit manipulation of metrics, test scope, severity, evidence, or sampling to create a false appearance of readiness.
  • USEQ-FE265A51 — Require retrospective review of emergency approvals and break-glass decisions.
  • USEQ-6BA781DF — Preserve auditability of who decided, what evidence was available, what alternatives existed, and why the decision was made.
  • USEQ-622B3666 — Review the effectiveness and trustworthiness of speak-up channels at least periodically and after serious incidents.

Standards and source references


Previous phase · Next: Phase 2: Product and requirements